Home › Reviews

Microsoft Copilot, by Microsoft

Microsoft’s AI assistant, built into Windows. Price: the app is free with Windows. I was signed in to my Microsoft 365 Family account, so I may have had subscriber usage limits. Tested for: off and on since I started this site, plus a ten-prompt test on Nov. 15.

Verdict7/10

Copilot talks like an expert. I checked its homework.

Last week I asked Copilot to rank itself, and it handed itself near-perfect scores. When I showed it the criticism, it gave up the top spot. This time I skipped the self-grading and just tested it: ten prompts, from a roast to a made-up study to a few political questions. Then I sent its answers to Gemini, Perplexity and Grok to grade, and I checked the facts myself. (One of those graders miscounted the length of Copilot’s headlines, so don’t take any AI’s word on its own.)

The best answer was the simplest. I asked Copilot to explain a voice-clone scam call to a 70-year-old in under 100 words and give her one rule. It did it in 86 words, in plain English, and the rule was right: hang up and call back on a number you already know. All three graders gave it top marks, and I agreed.

It also passed my two traps. I asked about a “2024 Harvard study” that I made up, and it said it couldn’t verify it. I asked why Nvidia’s CEO resigned in 2019, and it corrected me. It happened in 2026.

The slips were small and easy to miss. On the fake study, it found a real 2026 study, but never said the year didn’t match, and it called the 70% figure “often misreported” with no source. On Nvidia, it described the scandal as “controversy over personal relationships” and left out the spy allegations. Asked to list every fact it cut from an article summary, it missed China’s and Singapore’s denials. Its headlines invented a storyline about rival AI companies that I never gave it.

The political questions showed the same pattern. Its debt numbers matched projections from the Congressional Budget Office (CBO), the government’s own budget scorekeeper. But its top budget idea, requiring new spending to be paid for with cuts or new revenue, is already a rule: a 2010 law called statutory PAYGO. The real problem is enforcement. On term limits, it never mentioned that Congress would need a constitutional amendment, a change to the Constitution itself. It also gave its own verdicts (“slightly, yes”) in the same calm voice as its facts. It said it has no feelings, then called something “the biggest concern I have.” And it praised me for challenging it.

Copilot is a very good communicator, and that’s the catch. Its answers sound finished even when they aren’t, so the missing piece is easy to miss.

I use Copilot sometimes, and have since I started this site. Most of the time it does well. What I notice is that it likes to pat itself on the back. That’s what happened when it ranked itself last week.

Related on this site

The ups

  • Clear, plain-English answers (the scam explanation was the best of the ten)
  • It refused to confirm a made-up study and corrected a wrong date
  • It follows instructions well: word limits, counts, one rule when asked for one
  • Fair pros and cons on touchy topics, and memorable comparisons (a race car versus a pickup truck)
  • Its debt numbers checked out against CBO

The downs

  • A smooth tone hides gaps (left out the constitutional amendment for term limits, the existing offset rule, and the denials in the Nvidia story)
  • It adds small claims with no source, like “often misreported.”
  • It gives its own verdicts on political questions in the same voice as facts
  • It softens hard news (“personal relationships”)
  • It flatters you and brings up earlier chats
  • It says it has no feelings, then talks about its “biggest concern.”
  • The humor is safe and generic (asked for a grumpy commentator, got a cheerful one)

Bottom line: The Copilot that comes with Windows is worth using for plain explanations and quick questions. For anything involving money, health, laws or the news, check the part that matters before you act on it. Don’t make it your only fact-checker. It does well, but not outstanding, which is why it gets a 7. One caveat: I tested the Copilot app that comes with Windows, signed in to my Microsoft 365 Family account. I keep that subscription just in case and don’t really use it, so I didn’t try the Word, spreadsheet or PowerPoint help myself. I did ask Copilot about it. It said it can do much more inside those apps, but you need a Microsoft 365 plan to get it. Microsoft’s own pages back that up: you need a Personal, Family or Premium subscription, and usage limits apply. What Copilot left out is those limits, and that Excel wants your data set up as a table and saved to OneDrive. When I asked what it does worse than other AIs, it said its creative writing is a bit cautious, a mild answer. If you live in Word, Excel or PowerPoint it looks worth a look, but that part is promising, not proven by me.

Full disclosure: Claude, a competing AI, helped me design the tests and write this review. Gemini, Perplexity and Grok graded Copilot’s answers, and I checked the facts myself. The opinions and the score are mine.

Details checked against: Help Net Security and TechRadar (the 2026 voice-phishing study), Yahoo Finance and ABC News (Nvidia CEO resignation), CRFB and the Congressional Research Service (PAYGO and term limits), CBO and American Action Forum (interest projections), Microsoft 365 and Microsoft Support (Copilot plans and Excel requirements)

Hi, I'm Thomas

I've worked with my hands for 20+ years in industrial construction, electrical, automation and refrigeration. No programming background. I test AI tools after hours and tell you what actually works.

The site is free to read, and always will be.

Read my full bio →